V

Appendices

1. Measurements

Body measurements were taken using a ruler over the arching of the table rather than a flexible tape measure lying across the arching. This represents more accurately the actual distance from edge to edge as it would appear on a drawing. In all cases the measurements represent the instrument’s current condition. The measurements are in centimeters.

Since the table of a stringed instrument is almost always made from the wood of a coniferous tree, and because it is often impossible to tell with the naked eye the specific species, no reference to the species has been made in the descriptions. The only exception is the use of the German term Haselfichte, which refers to a type of spruce with a distinctive grain pattern.

Body Length

Measured from the edge of the table at the neck-body joint to the edge of the table beside the saddle or hookbar.

Body Width

Upper and lower bouts measured at their widest point, and the center bout at its narrowest. Where the widest point on the upper bout is actually the upper corner this is so stated.

Rib Height

Measured from the joint between the rib and the table to the joint between the rib and the back. The fold measurement is taken at the point where the back starts to slope toward the neck heel.

String Length

Measured from the joint between the top nut and the fingerboard to the top edge of the bridge facing the fingerboard.

2. Chronological List of Purchases

Date purchased

Instrument

September 1967

Joachim Tielke bass viol (c1685)

March 1968

Johann Hasert bass viol

October 1970

Jean-Nicolas Lambert bass viol

December 1970

Louis Guersan quinton

August 1972

Anton Wachter baroque cello

September 1972

Barak Norman bass viol

December 1972

Jean-Baptiste Dehaye Salomon pardessus

January 1973

Gregor Karpp bass viol

September 1973

Georg Sellas bass viol

November 1973

Louis Guersan pardessus

February 1974

Anonymous French treble

September 1974

Joachim Tielke treble viol

April 1975

Anonymous German bass viol

November 1975

John Rose bass viol (1584)

July 1976

Anonymous English cello

September 1976

Joachim Tielke bass viol (1691)

November 1977

Nicolas Bertrand bass viol

December 1979

Portrait of Carl Friedrich Abel

April 1984

William Turner treble viol

June 1984

Anonymous Bohemian bass viol

August 1985

Nicolò Amati cello

July 1986

John Rose bass viol (c1600)

Bequest from August Wenzinger

June 2002

Louis Moitessier cello

3. Instruments Formerly in the Caldwell Collection

In our days as serious collectors of Art Nouveau, we were advised by a major collector that the best way to build a world-class collection was to sell annually the bottom ten percent of one’s collection and use that money to buy one great piece. We found we could never do that. Both sentiment about the experience of purchasing each piece and really loving the pieces at the “bottom” kept us from engaging in that fiscally wise, but emotionally cold, process. We actually tried for a few years (at the same time we were building the viol collection) to deal in antiques. We even were looking for places to rent a shop. But we eventually realized that it was not in our makeup to buy and sell with impunity.

However, sometimes it is necessary to cull a collection in order to improve its focus. The following list is the result of that activity. Almost all of the instruments were sold in order to buy something else that was more desirable for the collection as a whole. We always have tried to find the perfect person for each instrument and never handed instruments over to a dealer to sell.

The most painful sale was of the Ouvrard seven string viol when we had to buy the viol that we sensed belonged to the head that we had owned for so many years (see no. 2). The story of finding the Ouvrard is worth telling even though the viol now belongs to our good friend and colleague, Mary Anne Ballard. Jim and I were on a quick trip to Europe in the summer of 1970. We spent a week in Paris and a week in London. On our arrival in London we were both stricken with food poisoning and taken to an isolation hospital because the authorities thought we might have typhoid fever. We were kept several days in separate buildings of this hospital until Jim begged the doctors to let us go. He told them that we had not seen the Victoria and Albert Museum yet, and they acquiesced. After the obligatory visit to the V&A, we gathered all our remaining energy to shop on Portobello Road, the major antique district. I still remember sitting on the curb of the street to rest and being stared at by the proper English. We saw a shop with a violin in the window, and although we were concentrating on Art Nouveau at the time, we went in. The dealer was sitting at his desk, speaking on the phone. After looking at the violin, Jim interrupted the dealer to ask if he had any other stringed instruments. The dealer asked if he could be more specific, and Jim answered, “Like a viola da gamba.” Without skipping a beat the dealer picked up his phone again and asked the caller, “Isn’t your viola da gamba for sale?” His wife was Joy Hall, a professional player in London. She had just turned the Ouvrard over to Tony Bingham to sell, so this was, in fact, how we met Tony and started working with him. That was one of those moments that changed our lives.

Instrument and date purchased

Maker, place and date made

Buyer and date sold

Cello (modern setup)
1960

Josef Kloz
Mittenwald, 18th century

Cassandra Luckhardt, 1994

Bass viol
1964

Heinrich
East Germany (undated)

Mary Anne Ballard, 1969

Bass viol
1964

Eugen Sprenger
Frankfurt am Main, 1959

Max Fuller, 1985

Cello (modern setup)
1965

Vincenzo Panormo
London, 1796

Ralph Curry, 1985

Lyra viol
1966

Kelischek
Georgia, 1966

[unknown], 1968

Bass viol
1970

Jean Ouvrard
Paris, 1743

Mary Anne Ballard, 1985

Baroque violin
1972

Bourlier
Paris, 18th century

Elizabeth Lane, 1982

Pardessus de viole
1972

Louis Guersan
Paris, 18th century

Laurie Castellano, 1989

Baroque violin
1973

Claude Pierray
Paris, 1718

Daniel Draley, 1985

Baroque cello
1974

Eugen Sprenger
Frankfurt am Main, 1934

Oberlin College, 1982

Bass viol
1976

Johann Joseph Elsler
Mainz, 1732

Michael Willens, 1985

Baroque cello
1981

“Stainer” label
Tyrol, 18th century

Rebecca Humphrey, 1985

Bass viol
1982

William Turner
London, 1650

John Mark Rozendaal, 1997

4. 20th-Century Instruments in the Caldwell Collection

Jim owned six viols when I met him. He had found a set of four Sprenger instruments (a treble, two tenors, and a bass) in 1964, and I learned to play on one of the East German instruments that were brought to the West variously bearing the names of Heinrich, Zeitner, or Zolch. He had also commissioned a highly decorated lyra viol in 1965, whose sound unfortunately did not match its beauty. We have continued to use the matched Sprenger tenors in the Oberlin Consort of Viols.

We found the Sprenger treble from 1935 in Frankfurt, where it was made. It is a beautiful instrument, made when Eugen Sprenger Sr., a fine maker, was working with August Wenzinger and others to copy historical models. My first baroque cello, a Sprenger now owned by Oberlin College, was also a product of that time. The third, unlabeled Sprenger treble viol was bought by my mother, who, after we pressed her to learn the viol, became an enthusiastic player.

Michael Heale made a beautiful copy of the anonymous French treble when he was restoring the original. We have often used it in the Oberlin Consort of Viols.

The Garavaglia cello was made at the request of Daniel Draley so I would have a modern cello to take on orchestra tours and play at the Blossom Festival, the Cleveland Orchestra’s summer venue, instead of exposing the Amati to the risks of travel and outdoor performance. It served that purpose very well, and since my retirement from the orchestra I have put gut strings on it and lend it to students for use as a classical-style cello.

 

 

Instrument

Maker

Place and Date Made

Treble viol

Eugen Sprenger

Frankfurt am Main, 1935

Treble viol

Eugen Sprenger (unlabeled)

Frankfurt am Main, undated

Treble viol

Eugen Sprenger

Frankfurt am Main, 1959

Tenor viol

Eugen Sprenger

Frankfurt am Main, 1959

Tenor viol

Eugen Sprenger

Frankfurt am Main, 1959

Treble viol (copy of the anonymous French treble in the collection)

Michael Heale

Guildford, England, 1980

Cello (modern setup)

Gary Garavaglia

Chicago, 1986

5. Museum Exhibitions

Smithsonian Institution, National Museum of American History, Washington, D.C.

“The Craft of Sound: Three Centuries of the Viola da Gamba” (Honoring the 75th birthday of August Wenzinger)

November 21–December 15, 1980

John Rose bass viol (1584)

John Rose viol head

Barak Norman bass viol

Joachim Tielke bass viol (c1685)

Nicolas Bertrand bass viol

Anonymous French treble viol

Louis Guersan pardessus

Louis Guersan quinton

Jean Ouvrard bass viol (formerly in collection)

Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, Massachusetts

“Bach, Handel, and Scarlatti”

April 30–July 28, 1985

Johann Hasert bass viol

Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, Ohio

“Lutes, Lovers and Lyres: Musical Imagery in the Collection”

February 14–June 4, 1989

Barak Norman bass viol

Allen Memorial Art Museum, Oberlin, Ohio

“Musica Humana: A Dialgue between Music and the Visual Arts”

March 26–June 30, 1996

Jean-Baptiste Dehaye Salomon pardessus

Gregor Karpp bass viol

Anton Wachter baroque cello

6. Discography

John Rose bass viol (1584)

Five- and Six-part Fantasies of William Lawes

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Classic Masters CMCD-1015

John Rose bass viol (c1600)

Five- and Six-part Fantasies of William Lawes

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Classic Masters CMCD-1015

Barak Norman bass viol

Henry Purcell, The Fantasies for Viols

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Gasparo GS-245

Joachim Tielke bass viol (c1685)

Marin Marais [and] Le Sieur de Ste. Colombe, Pieces for Two Viols

Catharina Meints, James Caldwell, and James Weaver

Cambridge Records CRS 2201

Masterpieces of the French Baroque

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

VoxBox SVBX 5142; VoxBox CD3X 3006

Austrian Court Music 1680–1780 [works by Ariosti, Fux, Biber, Lidl, and Schenck]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1979

Gasparo GS-206

Music of the Berlin Court [works by Graun, Quantz, and Benda]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1980

Gasparo GS-220

J.S. Bach, Three Sonatas for Viola da Gamba and Harpsichord

Catharina Meints and Doris Ornstein

Gasparo GS-212; Gasparo Gallante GG1001

Georg Philipp Telemann (1681–1767)

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1981

Gasparo GS-228; Gasparo Gallante GG-1008

Cleveland Baroque Soloists [works by Handel, Scarlatti, and Telemann]

Penelope Jensen, James Caldwell, Catharina Meints, and Doris Ornstein

Gasparo GS-213

Chamber Music of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

Gasparo GS-209CX

J.S. Bach, Brandenburg Concertos

Apollo’s Fire

Eclectra ECCD-2047

Johann Hasert bass viol

Austrian Court Music 1680–1780 [works by Ariosti, Fux, Biber, Lidl, and Schenck]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1979

Gasparo GS-206

J.S. Bach, Three Sonatas for Viola da Gamba and Harpsichord

Catharina Meints and Doris Ornstein

Gasparo GS-212; Gasparo Gallante GG1001

J.S. Bach, The Notebook of Anna Magdalena Bach

Igor Kipnis, Judith Blegen, Benjamin Luxon, and Catharina Meints

Nonesuch D2-79020; Nonesuch 79020-2

Georg Philipp Telemann (1681–1767)

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1981

Gasparo GS-228; Gasparo Gallante GG-1008

Anonymous German bass viol

Austrian Court Music 1680–1780 [works by Ariosti, Fux, Biber, Lidl, and Schenck]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1979

Gasparo GS-206

Chamber Music of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

Gasparo GS-209CX

Five- and Six-Part Fantasies of William Lawes

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Classic Masters CMCD-1015

Anoymous Bohemian bass viol (set up as a five-string cello for Suite No. 6)

J.S. Bach, Six Suites for Solo Cello

Sergei Istomin, cellist

Analekta FL 2 3114-5

Nicolas Bertrand bass viol

The 250th Commemoration of Marin Marais

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

Gasparo GS-202; Gasparo Gallante GG1002

J.S. Bach, St. Matthew Passion

Chicago Symphony Orchestra, Sir Georg Solti, conductor

London 421 177-2 LH3

Rameau [and] Royer, Pièces de Clavecin

Lisa Goode Crawford, Marilyn McDonald, and Catharina Meints

Gasparo Gallante GG-1006

Building Castles in the Sky

James Caldwell, Catharina Meints, and Lisa Goode Crawford

Gasparo Gallante GG-1006

Jean-Nicolas Lambert bass viol

Marin Marais [and] Le Sieur de Ste. Colombe, Pieces for Two Viols

Catharina Meints, James Caldwell, and James Weaver

Cambridge Records CRS 2201

Masterpieces of the French Baroque

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

VoxBox SVBX 5142; VoxBox CD3X 3006

The 250th Commemoration of Marin Marais

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

Gasparo GS-202; Gasparo Gallante GG1002

Music of the Berlin Court [works by Graun, Quantz, and Benda]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1980

Gasparo GS-220

Georg Philipp Telemann (1681–1767)

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1981

Gasparo GS-228; Gasparo Gallante GG-1008

Building Castles in the Sky

James Caldwell, Catharina Meints, and Lisa Goode Crawford

Boston Records BR1069CD

Anonymous French treble viol

Henry Purcell, The Fantasies for Viols

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Gasparo GS-245

Five- and Six-part Fantasies of William Lawes

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Classic Masters CMCD-1015

Sweet was the Song : Traditional Carols

Smithsonian Chamber Players with Max van Egmond

Smithsonian Collection of Recordings A-22008 / ND 040

Louis Guersan pardessus

Barthelemy de Caix, Six Sonatas for Two Pardessus de Viole

Duo Guersan (Catharina Meints and Tina Chancey)

Dorian Discovery DIS-80150

Louis Guersan quinton

Masterpieces of the French Baroque

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

VoxBox SVBX 5142; VoxBox CD3X 3006

The 250th Commemoration of Marin Marais

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

Gasparo GS-202; Gasparo Gallante GG1002

Anonymous English cello

Austrian Court Music 1680–1780 [works by Ariosti, Fux, Biber, Lidl, and Schenck]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1979

Gasparo GS-206

Music of the Berlin Court [works by Graun, Quantz, and Benda]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1980

Gasparo GS-220

Georg Philipp Telemann

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1981

Gasparo Gallante GG-1008

Handel Concerti Grossi, Opus 3

The Smithsonian Chamber Players

The Smithsonian Collection N023

Chamber Music of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

Gasparo GS-209CX

Building Castles in the Sky

James Caldwell, Catharina Meints, and Lisa Goode Crawford

Boston Records BR1069CD

Eugen Sprenger treble viol (1935)

Masterpieces of the French Baroque

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

VoxBox SVBX 5142; VoxBox CD3X 3006

Michael Heale treble viol

Henry Purcell, The Fantasies for Viols

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Gasparo GS-245

Five- and Six-part Fantasies of William Lawes

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Classic Masters CMCD-1015

Eugen Sprenger tenor viols (nos. 1 and 2)

Henry Purcell, The Fantasies for Viols

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Gasparo GS-245

Five- and Six-part Fantasies of William Lawes

Oberlin Consort of Viols

Classic Masters CMCD-1015

William Turner bass viol

The World of Lully

Chicago Baroque Ensemble (John Mark Rozendaal, director)

Cedille CDR 90000 043

The Virtuoso Handel

Chicago Baroque Ensemble (John Mark Rozendaal, director)

Cedille CDR 90000 057

“Bass”ically French [works by Marais, Corrette, and Philidor]

Mary Springfels, Michael McCraw, and others (including J.M. Rozendaal)

Centaur CRC 2704

Breaking the Ground: Music of Christopher Simpson’s The Division-Viol.

John Mark Rozendaal and David Schrader

Centaur CRC 2920

A German Bouquet

Trio Settecento (Rachel Barton Pine, John Mark Rozendaal, and David Schrader)

Cedille CDR 90000 114

Jean Ouvrard bass viol

Masterpieces of the French Baroque

Oberlin Baroque Ensemble

VoxBox SVBX 5142; VoxBox CD3X 3006

J.S. Bach, Three Sonatas for Viola da Gamba and Harpsichord

Catharina Meints and Doris Ornstein

Gasparo GS-212; Gasparo Gallante GG1001

Marin Marais, Pièces à deux violes (1686)

Kenneth Slowik, Jaap ter Linden, and Konrad Junghänel

Deutsche Harmonia Mundi 77146-2-RC

Bourlier baroque violin

Music of the Berlin Court [works by Graun, Quantz, and Benda]

Baroque Performance Institute, Oberlin, 1980

Gasparo GS-220

Eugen Sprenger baroque cello

Cleveland Baroque Soloists [works by Handel, Scarlatti, and Telemann]

Penelope Jensen, James Caldwell, Catharina Meints, and Doris Ornstein

Gasparo GS-213

Vincenzo Panormo cello

Jacques Ibert, Capriccio for Ten Instruments

Chamber Symphony of Philadelphia

RCA LSC 3089

Roussel, Trio for flute, viola, and cello; Pierné, Sonata da Camera for flute, cello, and piano

Robert Willoughby, Kathryn Plummer, Catharina Meints, and Wilbur Price

Gasparo GS-244; Gasparo Gallante GG1002